american youtuber krl

American Youtuber Impressed with Indonesia’s KRL, Compared to New York Subway

Share:

Indonesians, especially those who live in the Jabodetabek area (Jakarta, Bogor, Depok, Tangerang, Bekasi), are no strangers to the KRL. This commuter line mode of transportation is indeed a common choice for inter-city travel. 

Although reliable, the commuter line is also not immune from various criticisms. However, who would have thought that foreign tourists would praise this mode of transportation? 

An American YouTuber named Evan Ramani expressed his admiration for the commuter line. He even considers KRL better than the subway in New York!

He expressed his admiration in a video on his YouTube channel, That Evan Guy, titled “I CAN’T Believe Jakarta, Indonesia’s Infrastructure (USA Jealous).”

American Youtuber impressed with Indonesia's KRL

From the video he uploaded on Youtube, it can be seen that he boarded from Sawah Besar station. When entering the station he immediately praised it because the station was clean. According to him, the NYC subway is dirty and a lot of chewing gum garbage, even rats.

“I thought I would take public transportation, see how public transportation is here. Oh Good first impression! 

Clean, you know!” Evan said in the video.

Apart from being clean, he also likes Jakarta’s public transportation because it is more comfortable and safer than what he has tried in Chicago.

He also praised the actions of one of the male passengers on the train who was willing to stand up to give a seat to a woman.

“Oh, I just witnessed something amazing, and this is part of Indonesian culture. This young man sitting here, when this woman came, immediately stood up for her; what an experience. Eye opening!”

As an American Youtuber, he also uses the video to critique the development of public transportation/infrastructure in NYC. That Evan Guy’s video has been the talk of the town, not only among Jakartans but also among international audiences. 

Enjoyed this article? Explore other content from Social Expat for the latest updates on Travel News in Indonesia!

SEO Writer

Imelda is a content writer specializing in viral news and Indonesian culture. Her work revolves around researching and analyzing current events, social media trends, and popular culture.

Related News

A flash flood struck parts of Solok Regency in West Sumatra on Monday evening, 21 September, killing one person, leaving another missing and damaging homes, government offices, vehicles and road infrastructure. The flood hit Nagari Batang Barus in Gunung Talang District at around 19.30 WIB after heavy rainfall in Solok and surrounding areas. Floodwater carried […]

A 67-year-old Dutch woman, identified by her initials FMMM, has been placed at the Denpasar Immigration Detention Centre (Rudenim) after allegedly causing disturbances at a hotel and later at the Denpasar Immigration Office. The incident began after FMMM reportedly had a disagreement with the management of the hotel where she was staying. Local police received […]

A Ukrainian man has been detained in Bali after Indonesian immigration authorities accused him of acting as a broker for prostitution services involving foreign nationals on the island. The man, identified by the initials OG, was among 13 foreign nationals detained during a joint operation conducted by the Bali Regional Office of the Directorate General […]

Jakarta Governor Pramono Anung met New York City Mayor Zohran Kwame Mamdani at Civic Hall in New York on Sunday, 20 September 2026, for a bilateral discussion on urban challenges, including public transport, traffic congestion, flooding, air pollution and infrastructure financing. The meeting took place alongside the Urban 20 Mayors Summit 2026. Mamdani asked Pramono […]

Indonesia Guide

Just For Fun

Write For Us

Exclusive Promotions

Event Gallery